Celebrate summer with these paleo smores bars! They’re so easy to make with a 3 ingredient crust, 2 ingredient filling and 1 ingredient topping. And they’re entirely gluten free and paleo!
There are few things that are truly impossible to make a paleo version of, but graham crackers are one of them. See, the main ingredient in graham crackers is graham flour, which is a specific kind of wheat flour that makes a graham cracker…graham-y. So it took me awhile to figure out how to many a proper s’more without (wheat-y) graham crackers, let alone without grains altogether.
For awhile, I just sort of embraced it and used chocolate chip cookies to sandwich together the ingredients – because who is going to complain about that!? – but at some point, you just want that true s’mores flavor in your paleo s’mores, or else why bother?
This all kind of sounds like a very unconvincing lead up to the recipe, except for the big reveal, the secret ingredient, if you will. It’s…Simple Mills grain free cinnamon cookies (This is not sponsored by the way. These cookies just work really well as a paleo-friendly replacement for graham crackers!). OK, fine, “secret” might have been a stretch. You could probably use gluten free graham crackers, if you don’t mind the grains – I like Pamela’s brand gluten free honey graham crackers, but there are tons of other options out there – but in order to make these proper paleo s’mores, we need to start with a proper grain free base.
It turns out that once you’ve identified the right ingredients, the rest of the process is pretty simple, and quite familiar if you’ve had experience making these kind of no-bake/semi-baked bar cookies and treats.
The crust is made of crushed cookies and butter (or coconut oil, for a dairy-free variation). The food processor is the easiest crushing mechanism, and makes mixing in the butter or oil easy to do (pour in, turn machine on). But if you want to go low-tech, put all of the cookies in a zip top bag and roll/whack them with a rolling pin until they are completely crushed. Then transfer to a mixing bowl and stir the butter or oil in.
Then you press the cookie mixture into a lightly greased 8″x8″ baking dish and bake it for a few minutes, just to set the crust.
You can use any chocolate you want: dark, super dark, dairy free, etc. My go-to these days is Ghirardelli dark chocolate chips, but you don’t need to use chips. You can use a bar instead, but make sure to chop it up to about the size of large chocolate chips for faster and more even melting.
Speaking of the melting, you can do it over a double boiler or in the microwave. Be careful with the microwave, which can burn your chocolate, believe it or not, or cause it to seize. My favorite tricks for preventing burned or seized chocolate are:
- Heat in 30 second increments, stirring a bit between each one. This will, at first, seem like it’s not doing anything. Be patient. It will!
- Create a little hole in the center by pushing your chocolate out to the sides of the bowl. I don’t really understand the mechanics of how microwaves penetrate food or whatever, but the heat concentrates in the center of the bowl and that’s where the burning or seizing happens. Just make sure there is a space in the center of the bowl about the size of a half dollar (oh, there’s a reference you probably haven’t heard in awhile) without any chocolate chips or chunks in it.
- And if you do find yourself with seized chocolate, at a tiny bit of oil and stir vigorously to restore the texture. You may need a little bit more than the recipe calls for (the amount called for is enough to keep the chocolate from totally firming up so you an bite into it more easily), but add about 1 tsp at a time at most. If your chocolate burns, though, throw it out and start over. You’ll know the difference because burned chocolate smells like, well, burning.
Marshmallows aren’t exactly an every day food, or really more than a once a year food in my house, but since this is a special occasion, super decadent dessert, so we’re going to go ahead and let them slide. If you’re going for store-bought, there are many less-unhealthy brands out there. Peruse the baking aisle at Whole Foods for a few reliable options, like Dandies.
Alternately, you can make your own. I don’t have a recipe on this site, but you can do a search for a recipe. There are plenty out there.
And a word of warning about the toasting process: you’ll add the marshmallow layer to the pan and then stick the whole thing under the broiler to toast the ‘mallows. BE CAREFUL. Even 30 seconds can mean the difference between toasted and burned or burned and burning the house down (ok, that’s a slight exaggeration, I think, but let’s not test it). Be careful with the broiler, watch this step very, very carefully, and pull the bars out at the first sign of toastiness. I put my pan on the top rack of the oven, about 6-8″ or so from the broiler and it took just short of 90 seconds (probably around 80 seconds). Start with 45 seconds, then add 15 seconds of toasting at a time until the marshmallows reach your desired degree of toastiness.
Ok holy moly that was a lot of information about a recipe that basically goes: “break cookies, press into pan, cover with melted chocolate and marshmallows and eat”. There I go overcomplicating things again. I’ll just excuse myself and let you get to it!
Paleo S'Mores BarsPrint Pin Rate
Ingredients for the crust
Ingredients for the topping
- 20 large marshmallows, cut in half widthwise (across the middle)
- Preheat the oven to 350°F. Lightly grease an 8'x8' baking dish and set aside.
- In the bowl of a food processor fitted with the "s" blade, pulse the cookies several times until chopped.
- Add the butter (or oil) and process until the cookies are crushed. The mixture should hold together when pressed.
- Turn the cookie mixture into the prepared pan. Use your hand to pat it firmly into an even layer.
- Bake for about 15 minutes, until firm.
- While the crust is baking, melt the chocolate and oil together, either in the microwave (in 30-second increments) or on the stove in a double boiler, stirring constantly.
- When the chocolate is smooth, pour it into the baked crust and smooth into an even layer. Allow it to set in the fridge for 20-30 minutes.
- Top with marshmallow halves, cut side down.
- Turn on your oven's broiler and situate a rack near the top (about 6-8" from the heat). Place the pan in the oven for 45-60 seconds. Check the toastiness of the marshmallows, and if you'd like them to be toasted more, put them under the broiler in 15 second increments, checking in between, until toasted to your liking.
- Cut and serve.
- You can use any gluten free or grain free cookies you prefer, but I recommend (and used here) Simple Mills grain free cinnamon cookies. If you're looking for a gluten free graham cracker, I've enjoyed Pamela's honey graham crackers, but there are many options out there.
- If you're having trouble patting the cookie mixture into the pan, try covering it with a piece of wax or parchment paper and press on the parchment.
- If you'd rather use a chocolate bar instead of chips, you will need about 6 ounces, chopped.
- Take care in melting the chocolate because too much heat too quickly will cause it to burn or seize. My favorite tricks for preventing burned or seized chocolate are:
- Heat in 30 second increments, stirring a bit between each one. This will, at first, seem like it's not doing anything. Be patient. It will!
- Create a little hole in the center by pushing your chocolate out to the sides of the bowl. I don't really understand the mechanics of how microwaves penetrate food or whatever, but the heat concentrates in the center of the bowl and that's where the burning or seizing happens. Just make sure there is a space in the center of the bowl about the size of a half dollar (oh, there's a reference you probably haven't heard in awhile) without any chocolate chips or chunks in it.
- And if you do find yourself with seized chocolate, at a tiny bit of oil and stir vigorously to restore the texture. You may need a little bit more than the recipe calls for (the amount called for is enough to keep the chocolate from totally firming up so you an bite into it more easily), but add about 1 tsp at a time at most. If your chocolate burns, though, throw it out and start over. You'll know the difference because burned chocolate smells like, well, burning.
- Store leftover bars in an airtight container for up to three days at room temperature.
Products from Amazon.com